Made to feel quite white (and rightly so) by Gwendolyn Brooks ...
(Modern Poetry is reading the excellent Ms. Brooks this week.)
Early-nineties. In the presence of Ms. Brooks and one of my students, I said something ... a comment on skin-tone distinctions w/in the black community ("yellow" more valued than "black") ... and received the most withering over-the-top-of-the-eyeglasses glance I'd ever care to receive from anyone. As in "really? and who are you?" And all my liberal white-guy defenses kicked in. And I shut up. It struck me that some people think that some people don't really have The Right to say anything about certain things. And it struck me that they are right to think so.
GB 1972:
"There is indeed a new black today. He [sic] is different from any the world has known. He's a tall-walker. Almost firm. By many of his own brothers he is not understood. And he is understood by no white. Not the wise white; not the Schooled white; not the Kind white. Your least pre-requisite toward an understanding of the new black is an exceptional Doctorate which can be conferred only upon those with the proper properties of bitter birth and intrinsic sorrow. I know this is infuriating, especially to those professional Negro-understanders, some of them so very kind, with special portfolio, special savvy. But I cannot say anything other, because nothing other is the truth." ("The New Black")
It struck me that - given her many travels to schools throughout the state as poet laureate - she must have run into "my kind" before. I got that in the glance. I silently protested ... But I'm not like that ... you don't know me ...
Context ain't everything ... but it comes pretty close sometimes. What was hers, mine, and ours in that early-nineties moment? What was hers and theirs in 1972?
Race has always made everything impossible. When it is present as text or subtext in any relation, it precludes trust ... and demands that impossible game of explaining that I'm not thinking what you think I'm thinking just because I look like the kind of person who would be thinking what you think I'm thinking. And such. Yech. Makes one cry. You don't know me. And yes. I don't know you. So. There must not be anything we can say to each other.
But. From the page. From off your pages, I hear you. And. May I understand. That.
Even though it may not have been written for me to read. Accidental interloper. Better stand in these shadows. But I hear you.
And the condition for the possibility of my beginning to understand. Exists. Does exist.
(or was i / am I utterly irrelevant to ...)